Recently I read couple of books on alternative medicine, see
book titles below.
Both books basically said alternative medicine don’t offer
any real benefit, any perceived benefit is purely a placebo effect. I was especially interested in the section
on acupuncture and herbal medicine because I had some personal experiences on
both. Following were three different
conditions that I have treated with acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine
with mixed result.
Hypertension
My first experience I had with Traditional Chinese Medicine
(TCM) was in mid-1990. I was taking
couple of medication to control my high blood pressure. While the medication worked fairly well but
I really hated the side effects. I
happen to read an article about TCM and its effectiveness on high blood
pressure. Even though I was very
skeptical about how the Chi, a.k.a life energy, would affect one's health, I gave
TCM a try just in case it really works.
During the first session the TCM doctor took my pulse on the
wrist, looked at my tongue and declared me I had kidney deficiency, which would
affect my blood pressure. . The TCM doctor didn’t even check my blood
pressure or ask what medication I was taking.
She prescribed acupuncture, cupping, and Chinese herbal medicine to
treat my kidney deficiency. When I ask
her how soon would I see improvement, she just said everyone is different, and
I might take many acupuncture sessions to see improvement.
During the first session, I had about two dozens of needles
placed all over my body front and back.
Couple of needles was connected to some sort of electronic device for
electric stimulation. I also had
cupping done on the back of my body. At
the end of the session I was given a bottle of pills for kidney health. I was told not to take my medication and
the Chinese herbal pill at the same time.
I went for three more acupuncture and cupping sessions. I had a very accurate blood pressure monitor
at home and I didn’t see much change in my reading between sessions. When I question the result, she just said
TCM treatment is very gentle and may take long time to work for some people and
told me keep coming for the treatment. She also said I have to have faith in acupuncture in order for it to work. What the heck? Is TCM a religion?
I decided not to continue with TCM treatment after four
sessions because I didn’t see any tangible result for my money. Who know, TCM might work for me in few more
sessions but it is getting too costly for me.
Beside my medication and exercise regiment seem to control my blood pressure
fairly well at much lower cost.
Tinnitus and Vertigo
In early 2000, I began to have ringing in my ear, a
condition known as tinnitus. I also
experienced fullness in the ear, which often time caused vertigo attack. The vertigo attack could happen at anytime
with little warning. The severity of
the vertigo attack could very mild, which only cause slight sense of losing
balance to very severe, which I couldn’t even stand up.
To make the story short, an ENT specialist treated me for
the first few months without any success.
The vertigo was getting worst and I missed many work days. Some thime I couldn’t even get out of bed
because I had the sensation of everything spin around me. I had a MRI on my head and ear and
everything were normal. I tried few
medications and had no relief from the vertigo. The ENT thought I might have meniere's disease but he need to do
more tests to confirm it. By then I was
sick and tire of all the tests and medications. I had the feeling the doctor had no clue on what’s wrong with my
ear.
Out of desperation,
I went to see a TCM doctor for help.
This is a different TCM doctor, he was a MD as well as TCM doctor. After he checked my blood pressure, took my
pulse, and looked at my tongue, he said I have kidney deficiency. He said acupuncture and Chinese medicine
should help my condition. He also said
I should see improvement in about 10 treatments.
I noticed some improvement with tinnitus after the first
acupuncture treatment. I had two
treatments per week. I had about dozen
of needles in my body at each acupuncture session. Couple of needles were attached to an electronics device. After six treatments, my innitus was
completely gone. I haven’t had any
major vertigo attack for years. I still
have very mild dizziness once in a long while.
So, if this is a placebo effect, I like it and money well spent. However, I don't think my cure had anything to do with acupuncture, but rather probably coincident with unexplained remission, there still a lot we don't know about our body. The doctor might be just lucky to hit a nerve to turn off my problems. The next person who sought this treatment might not be that lucky.
Over Active Bladder
Last year, I start having over active bladder issue. After trying five different medications, I
finally found one that was somewhat helpful but I don’t really like the side
effects. So I gave TCM another try.
The TCM doctor who treated my tinnitus and vertigo had moved
to another city and I found another TCM doctor who said one of her specialty
was treating bladder issue. On my first
visit, she took my pulse and looked at my tongue and declared me I had kidney
deficiency, what the heck? BTW, as part of medical exam, my kidneys
were checked by my urologist and they were normal. I did some checking, it seem that kidney deficiency got blamed for many
ailments.
I had four acupuncture treatments with this doctor and had
no improvement at all. In all four acupuncture sessions, she placed couple needles
at my lower abdominal area, my ankles, and wrists. The needles at my abdominal were hooked up to electrodes. I had strong contraction with my bladder
when the electrodes were on and had very strong urge to pee. I thought that was good sign because my
bladder was reacting to the acupuncture but it didn’t really improve my
situation after treatments. The doctor
urged me to try few more sessions but I decided to stop because I don’t think
it would help.
My bladder problem was later determined caused by enlarged prostate and was treated with GreenLight laser surgery. I talk about the surgery in this later blog post.
My bladder problem was later determined caused by enlarged prostate and was treated with GreenLight laser surgery. I talk about the surgery in this later blog post.
Would I try acupuncture treatment on retinitis
Pigmentosa? Probably not but I keep the option open. The challenge is to find a local acupuncturist who know how to treat RP. I had mentioned to the last two TCM doctors that I have RP, but they just gave me a questioning look. Apparently they never heard of RP let alone knowing how to treat it. Anyway, if the next TCM doctor I find say my RP is due to kidney deficiency, I probably just walk out.
Couple of small studies seem to suggest acupuncture might help RP. See my blog post on RP treatment.
Couple of small studies seem to suggest acupuncture might help RP. See my blog post on RP treatment.
Books
If you have access to BARD, you can download the following 2
books. They are very informative about
alternative medicine.
- Trick
or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative Medicine. By Edzard Ernst and Simon Singh. Book Review
- Do You
Believe In Magic?: The Sense and Nonsense of Alternative Medicine. By Paul Offit, MD. Book Review
